The Bravo universe thrives on drama, but few stories have simmered as long as the rumors surrounding Craig Conover’s behavior at Amanda Batula and Kyle Cooke’s wedding. For years, fans speculated about what really happened that night—was the Southern Charm star truly kicked out, or was it all just Bravo-fueled hearsay? Now, in a bombshell revelation, Paige DeSorbo has finally set the record straight, confirming the rumors and exposing the truth behind Craig Conover’s headline-making exit.
Table of Contents
The Night That Sparked the Rumors
Craig Conover’s name has been linked to chaos before, but nothing quite compares to the spectacle at Amanda Batula and Kyle Cooke’s wedding in September 2021. The event, held in the backyard of Batula’s parents’ New Jersey home, was meant to be a celebration of love and friendship. Instead, it became the setting for one of Bravo’s most infamous off-camera scandals.
For years, whispers circulated among fans and cast members alike. Some claimed Craig was simply having too much fun; others insisted he was asked to leave after causing a scene. The truth remained elusive—until now.
Paige DeSorbo Breaks Her Silence
During the much-anticipated Summer House Season 9 reunion, Paige DeSorbo finally addressed the elephant in the room. She confirmed that her then-boyfriend, Craig Conover, was not just politely asked to leave—he was told not to return to the backyard, effectively ending his night at the wedding.
According to Paige, Craig’s behavior was nothing short of embarrassing. She described him as “excessively intoxicated,” recounting how he kicked tables, shouted at guests, and repeatedly ignored the Batulas’ request for guests to remain outdoors. Despite her pleas the next morning for him to apologize to Amanda and her family, Craig refused. Paige admitted, “I was embarrassed. He acted like an entitled brat at the wedding and was a source of shame.”
Amanda Batula corroborated Paige’s account, explaining that it was Paige who reached out the next day to apologize for Craig’s actions. Amanda described the incident as mortifying, adding another layer of validation to the years-long speculation.
Craig Conover’s Side: Denial and Deflection
For his part, Craig Conover has consistently denied being kicked out of the wedding. In interviews, he has claimed the story was exaggerated and insisted that if he had truly been ejected, it would have been caught on camera. He acknowledged drinking too much but maintained that he left of his own accord and was merely “asked not to come back in.”
However, Kyle Cooke himself set the record straight during Season 9, Episode 5 of Summer House. He stated unequivocally, “Make no mistake, the guy got kicked out of my wedding. He continues to lie about that.” With both Amanda and Kyle confirming the incident, Craig’s denials appear increasingly hollow.
The Fallout: Relationships and Reputations
The aftermath of the wedding scandal rippled through the Bravo community. Paige and Craig’s relationship, already under scrutiny, faced new challenges. Paige revealed that her feelings began to shift when Craig refused to publicly defend her and failed to take responsibility for his actions at the wedding. She ultimately ended their relationship in late 2024, a decision she described as the right one for her own peace of mind.
Meanwhile, the rumor mill continued to churn. Paige initially accused Lindsay Hubbard of leaking the story to the press, only to later discover that it was actually Danielle Olivera. Danielle admitted to sharing the story, calling it “juicy as f***” and expressing no regrets about her actions. This revelation added another layer of drama, highlighting the complexities of loyalty and trust within the Bravo cast.
A Timeline of Events
To clarify the sequence of events, here’s a breakdown:
- September 2021: Amanda Batula and Kyle Cooke marry in New Jersey. Craig Conover, dating Paige DeSorbo, attends.
- Wedding Night: Craig becomes excessively intoxicated, causes a scene, and is asked to leave the backyard by the Batulas.
- Following Morning: Paige urges Craig to apologize; he refuses. Paige contacts Amanda’s parents to apologize on his behalf.
- Rumors Circulate: Speculation about Craig’s ejection spreads online and among cast members.
- 2024: Paige and Craig’s relationship ends. Danielle Olivera admits to leaking the story.
- March 2025: Kyle Cooke publicly confirms Craig was kicked out.
- June 2025: Paige DeSorbo reveals the full story during the Summer House reunion.
The Impact on Bravo’s Social Circles
This incident didn’t just affect Paige and Craig’s relationship; it sent shockwaves through the broader Bravo community. Friendships were tested as cast members took sides or tried to keep the peace. Amanda Batula admitted she was surprised, though not shocked, by Paige and Craig’s eventual breakup. Paige, for her part, said she stopped defending Craig after the split, reflecting on how often she felt compelled to cover for his behavior during their relationship.
The drama also highlighted the blurred lines between personal and public life for reality TV stars. Private moments, like a wedding, became fodder for public consumption and debate. The cast’s handling of the incident—some choosing to leak details, others remaining silent—underscored the challenges of maintaining trust and authenticity in the spotlight.
Where Are They Now?
Since the breakup, both Paige DeSorbo and Craig Conover have moved on. Paige is dating again, though she describes her current relationships as “nothing serious” with “no one special.” Craig, meanwhile, has been linked to model Natalie Buffett.
Despite the tumultuous end to their romance, Paige has expressed that she’s in a good place. She’s focused on herself, her friendships, and her career, free from the drama that once defined her relationship with Craig.
Lessons from the Craig Conover Wedding Scandal
The saga surrounding Craig Conover’s behavior at Amanda Batula and Kyle Cooke’s wedding offers several takeaways:
- Accountability matters: Craig’s refusal to apologize or take responsibility for his actions contributed to the breakdown of his relationship with Paige.
- Truth always comes out: Despite years of denials and rumors, the real story eventually emerged.
- Friendship and loyalty are tested in the spotlight: The Bravo cast’s handling of the incident revealed the complexities of maintaining trust in a public setting.
Conclusion: The End of the Rumor Mill
With Paige DeSorbo’s candid revelations, the Craig Conover wedding scandal has finally been put to rest. Fans now know exactly what happened that night—and why it mattered. The incident serves as a cautionary tale about the consequences of entitlement, the importance of accountability, and the enduring power of truth in the world of reality television.
Bravo fans, what do you think about Paige’s decision to come clean? Has your opinion of Craig Conover changed? Join the conversation and share your thoughts below!
Stay tuned for more exclusive updates and inside scoops from the world of Bravo.
Share your thoughts on the Craig Conover wedding drama and let us know whose side you’re on in the comments!