In this week’s standout episode of Poker Face, Alia Shawkat emerges as a formidable foe, captivating audiences with her layered performance as Kate Forster in “A New Lease On Death.” The latest installment, which premiered on Peacock June 19, 2025, sees Natasha Lyonne’s Charlie Cale settling into a Brooklyn apartment, only to find herself tangled in a web of deception and murder. Shawkat’s portrayal of Kate, a charming yet ruthless criminal, has quickly become the talk of social media, with fans and critics alike praising her ability to balance menace and magnetism.
Set in a vibrant New York City apartment complex, the episode marks a new chapter for Charlie as she temporarily takes over Good Buddy’s Brooklyn digs. The eclectic cast of neighbors includes Lauren Tom as Anne, Awkwafina as Maddy, and David Alan Grier as Otto, the cranky building manager. Yet, it’s Alia Shawkat’s scheming Kate who steals the spotlight, weaving herself into Anne’s life with sinister intentions. The episode’s suspenseful plot and strong ensemble have drawn comparisons to Only Murders in the Building, thanks to its blend of mystery, humor, and heart.
Table of Contents
Alia Shawkat’s Villainous Turn
Alia Shawkat’s Kate Forster is no ordinary antagonist. Her character enters Anne’s life with a seemingly innocent meet-cute at a fruit stand, but quickly reveals a dark agenda. Kate, who also goes by Amelia Peek, is revealed to be a career criminal with a string of warrants and a history of manipulation. Her goal? To secure Anne’s rent-controlled apartment by any means necessary, including orchestrating the murder of Anne’s granddaughter, Maddy.
Shawkat’s performance is both chilling and charismatic. She infuses Kate with a sense of danger and unpredictability, making her a worthy adversary for Charlie. Reviews highlight how Shawkat excels at playing complex, morally ambiguous characters, drawing on her experience in shows like Arrested Development and Search Party. Her chemistry with Natasha Lyonne is electric, and their scenes crackle with tension and wit. Fans have taken to platforms like Instagram and YouTube to share clips and reactions, with many praising Shawkat’s ability to make Kate both charming and terrifying.
The episode’s narrative keeps viewers on their toes, as Kate’s true motives unfold and Charlie races to uncover the truth. Shawkat’s portrayal is a masterclass in subtle menace, with moments of vulnerability that make Kate all the more unsettling. As the story reaches its climax, Charlie and Anne team up to expose Kate’s crimes, leading to a satisfying sting operation that showcases both characters’ resilience and ingenuity.
Brooklyn, Rent Control, and the Power of Community
“A New Lease On Death” is more than just a murder mystery—it’s a love letter to New York City and its diverse communities. The episode’s setting in a Brooklyn apartment complex allows for a rich tapestry of characters, each with their own quirks and stories. Charlie’s decision to take over Good Buddy’s apartment marks a rare moment of stability for her, as she grapples with the chaos of her nomadic life.
The episode explores themes of trust, betrayal, and the lengths people will go to in the pursuit of security. Rent control becomes a central plot device, highlighting the pressures and conflicts that arise in a city where affordable housing is scarce. The eclectic cast, including Ricardo the librarian and Otto the landlord, adds depth and humor to the story, while Charlie’s interactions with her neighbors reveal her growing connection to the community.
Alia Shawkat’s Kate is the catalyst for much of the episode’s drama, but it’s the ensemble’s performances that truly bring the story to life. Lauren Tom’s Anne is a standout, navigating loss and justice with grace and determination. Awkwafina’s Maddy, though given less screen time, delivers a memorable performance that balances comedy and pathos. David Alan Grier’s Otto provides comic relief, while also serving as a reminder of the building’s history and character.
Key Point Summary
- Alia Shawkat plays Kate Forster, a formidable and manipulative villain in Poker Face Season 2, Episode 9.
- The episode, “A New Lease On Death,” premiered June 19, 2025, on Peacock.
- Charlie Cale (Natasha Lyonne) takes over Good Buddy’s Brooklyn apartment, setting the stage for a gripping mystery.
- Shawkat’s character orchestrates a murder plot to steal Anne’s rent-controlled apartment, showcasing her talent for playing complex antagonists.
- The episode is praised for its strong ensemble, suspenseful plot, and homage to New York City’s diverse communities.
- Fans and critics highlight Shawkat’s chemistry with Lyonne and her ability to balance charm and menace.
- The story explores themes of trust, betrayal, and the challenges of urban living.
Engaging Conclusion
Alia Shawkat’s turn as Kate Forster in Poker Face is a testament to her versatility and screen presence. Her performance elevates an already compelling episode, making “A New Lease On Death” a must-watch for fans of mystery and character-driven storytelling. With its sharp writing, memorable guest stars, and vibrant New York setting, the episode cements Poker Face as a standout in the crowded landscape of streaming television.
Want to see Alia Shawkat at her villainous best? Stream “A New Lease On Death” on Peacock now and join the conversation about this week’s most talked-about episode.