The question of who is Dominik Mysterio real father has captivated WWE fans for nearly two decades, stemming from one of wrestling’s most memorable storylines involving Rey Mysterio and Eddie Guerrero. Despite ongoing character-driven references to Eddie Guerrero as his “Papí,” the biological truth remains clear and documented.
Dominik Gutiérrez, known professionally as Dominik Mysterio, was born on April 5, 1997, to Angie and Óscar Gutiérrez, better known as Rey Mysterio. This Mexican-American heritage connects him to a legendary wrestling lineage that extends beyond his famous father.
Table of Contents
The Eddie Guerrero Storyline That Started It All
The confusion surrounding Dominik’s paternity stems from WWE’s 2005 “Custody of Dominik” storyline. When Dominik was just 8 years old, he became directly involved in a storyline where his father battled Eddie Guerrero over his legal custody. This dramatic narrative culminated in a ladder match at SummerSlam 2005, forever embedding the question in wrestling folklore.
The creative team developed a storyline where Eddie Guerrero revealed that he was the biological father of Dominik Mysterio, claiming he only allowed Rey to adopt him and now wanted him back. The storyline was so compelling that it affected Dominik’s real life outside the ring.
In interviews, Dominik has recalled having to explain to his teachers that Eddie Guerrero wasn’t actually his father, demonstrating how the fictional narrative spilled into his everyday childhood experience.
Dominik’s Modern Connection to Eddie Guerrero
Fast-forward to today, and Dominik continues to honor Eddie Guerrero’s memory in both subtle and obvious ways. On Father’s Day 2025, WWE Intercontinental Champion Dominik Mysterio honored Eddie Guerrero, taking a subtle jab at Rey Mysterio.
In June 2025, Dominik fulfilled a promise to visit Eddie Guerrero’s grave with his WWE Intercontinental Championship title belt, showing his continued respect for the late wrestling legend who played such a significant role in his childhood.
Recent custom sneaker tributes have also showcased Dominik’s connection to Eddie Guerrero, with Travis Scott x Air Jordan 1 Low customs created in honor of his “real” father.
The Biological Reality
While the storyline connection to Eddie Guerrero remains a powerful part of Dominik’s character development, the biological facts are straightforward. Dominik’s real and biological father is indeed the legendary luchador Rey Mysterio.
Dominik represents a third-generation professional wrestler, following his father Rey Mysterio and great-uncle Rey Misterio Sr. This wrestling lineage traces through the Gutiérrez family, not through Eddie Guerrero’s genetic line.
Career Impact and Character Development
The paternal storyline has significantly influenced Dominik’s WWE character development. During his rise as a heel character, Dominik has repeatedly brought up Eddie Guerrero and previously told Rey Mysterio that he wished Eddie was his real dad.
Following his memorable turn against Rey Mysterio at WWE Clash at the Castle 2022, Dominik has expressed that reconciliation with his “father” is no longer possible, referring to Eddie Guerrero’s passing.
Wrestling Legacy and Future
Dominik began training in 2017 and started appearing with his father on WWE television in 2019, before making his official debut match in 2020. His career trajectory shows clear influence from both Rey Mysterio’s technical expertise and Eddie Guerrero’s charismatic heel work.
The ongoing character work allows Dominik to honor both wrestling legends while carving out his own identity in WWE. His current role as Intercontinental Champion demonstrates his evolution beyond the shadow of either father figure.
The question continues to generate discussion among wrestling fans, particularly as Dominik maintains his character’s connection to Eddie Guerrero while building upon his legitimate wrestling heritage from Rey Mysterio. This dual influence creates a unique dynamic that keeps audiences engaged with both the fictional narrative and real family legacy.
What do you think about Dominik’s handling of this complex family storyline? Share your thoughts on how this wrestling drama has shaped one of WWE’s most intriguing character developments.