Last night, the American Idol stage lit up with Disney magic, but the American Idol vote sent shockwaves through the fanbase. On May 11, 2025, the Top 7 contestants belted out Disney classics at Disneyland, mentored by Lin-Manuel Miranda, only to see two fan favorites, Gabby Samone and Mattie Pruitt, eliminated. The Top 5—Slater Nalley, Breanna Nix, John Foster, Jamal Roberts, and Thunderstorm Artis—now stand, but the internet is buzzing with debates over who deserved to stay. Let’s dive into the drama, performances, and what’s next for these rising stars, keeping you hooked on every twist of this vocal rollercoaster.
American Idol Vote: Disney Night’s Highs and Heartbreaks
Disney Night was a spectacle, with contestants pulling out all the stops. Breanna Nix, now the last woman standing, delivered a soulful rendition of “Reflection” from Mulan, earning praise for her emotional depth. Jamal Roberts tackled “Hercules’” “Go the Distance,” with fans on X calling him the one to beat. Thunderstorm Artis, securing the final Top 5 spot, brought chills with “You’ll Be in My Heart” from Tarzan. Yet, the American Idol vote shocked viewers when Gabby Samone, lauded for her flawless “Circle of Life,” and Mattie Pruitt, who charmed with “Part of Your World,” were sent packing. Posts on X erupted, with fans like @LamontJunior declaring Gabby’s exit a travesty, predicting a limitless career ahead.
The eliminations sparked heated discussions. Some argued Slater Nalley’s upbeat “Hakuna Matata” didn’t match Gabby’s vocal prowess, while others felt John Foster’s safe “You’ve Got a Friend in Me” paled against Mattie’s sparkle. The American Idol app, website, and text voting (to 21523) gave America the power, but the results left many questioning the process. Were fans swayed by popularity over talent? The debate rages on.
Who Was Eliminated on ‘American Idol’? The Fallout
Gabby Samone and Mattie Pruitt’s eliminations hit hard. Gabby, a vocal powerhouse, had fans comparing her to past Idol legends, with
@MaggiesMusings calling her exit a “travesty.” Mattie, known for her youthful energy, also left a void. Their departures, announced live on ABC, marked a turning point, leaving Breanna Nix as the sole female contender. The Top 5 now face intense pressure as the competition tightens. Fans are already speculating on social media about who’ll crack under the spotlight and who’ll shine.
What’s next for Gabby and Mattie? History shows Idol eliminations don’t spell the end. Look at Jennifer Hudson or Chris Daughtry—both turned early exits into thriving careers. Gabby’s already got fans pledging support, and Mattie’s charm could land her a Disney gig. The American Idol vote may have closed their chapter, but their stories are just beginning.
Watch the ‘American Idol’ Top 5 2025 Perform Live: What’s Coming
- Slater Nalley: His energetic style divides fans, but his showmanship keeps him safe.
- Breanna Nix: The last woman standing, her soulful voice is a fan favorite.
- John Foster: Critics call him safe, but his consistency might carry him far.
- Jamal Roberts: A frontrunner, with fans betting on his powerful performances.
- Thunderstorm Artis: His emotional depth makes him a dark horse to watch.
The next episode, airing live on ABC, will see these five battle for America’s votes. With only a few weeks left, every performance counts. Will Breanna hold her own against the men? Can Jamal maintain his lead? Fans are urged to vote via the American Idol app, website, or text to shape the outcome. The show’s coast-to-coast broadcast ensures everyone gets a say, so don’t miss your chance to influence the American Idol vote.
Why the American Idol Vote Matters
This season’s voting has sparked more than just casual chatter. It’s a cultural moment, reflecting what America values in its next music star. The American Idol vote isn’t just about singing—it’s about connection, story, and charisma. Fans on X are dissecting every choice, from song selection to stage presence. Some praise the diversity of the Top 5, while others lament the loss of vocal heavyweights like Gabby. The live voting system, with options like the app or texting, empowers viewers, but it also fuels debates about fairness. Are casual voters drowning out dedicated fans? It’s a question as old as the show itself.
The Top 5’s performances next week will test their versatility. Rumors swirl about a possible ’80s theme or duets, which could shake up the leaderboard. Breanna’s soul, Jamal’s power, and Thunderstorm’s heart will face off in a clash of styles. Fans are already rallying behind their favorites, with #IdolTop5 trending on X. The American Idol vote will decide who inches closer to the crown, and every vote counts.
The Road to the Finale
As we head toward the American Idol finale, the tension is palpable. The Top 5 represent a mix of grit, talent, and heart, but only one can win. Breanna Nix carries the hopes of fans rooting for a female champion, while Jamal Roberts and Thunderstorm Artis are neck-and-neck in fan polls. Slater and John, though polarizing, have loyal bases that could pull them through. The American Idol vote will shape the narrative, and America’s choices will echo beyond the stage.
Tune in next Sunday at 8e/5p on ABC to watch the Top 5 perform live. Grab your phone, download the American Idol app, or text to 21523 to make your voice heard. The eliminations of Gabby and Mattie remind us how unpredictable this journey is, but that’s what keeps us glued to our screens. Who’ll rise, who’ll fall, and who’ll claim the title? Let’s find out together.