Are Willson Contreras and William Contreras brothers? This is a question that many baseball fans across the United States have been asking, especially as both players continue to make headlines during the 2025 MLB season. The answer is yes — they are brothers. Their shared journey from Venezuela to becoming two of the league’s most talented and respected catchers is a story that stands out in the world of sports.
Table of Contents
A Baseball Dream Born in Venezuela
Willson and William Contreras were born in Puerto Cabello, Venezuela, where baseball is more than a game — it’s a way of life. Raised in a close-knit family, the brothers developed their skills through daily backyard games, local leagues, and an unbreakable sibling bond. Their parents, William Sr. and Olga, nurtured their talent and encouraged their ambitions, even during challenging times.
Willson, the older of the two, was the first to pursue professional baseball. He signed with the Chicago Cubs as an international free agent in 2009 and spent years working his way up through the minor leagues. His MLB debut came in 2016, and it was unforgettable — he hit a home run on the very first pitch he faced at Wrigley Field. That season, he became a key figure in the Cubs’ historic World Series victory, their first in 108 years.
William followed in his brother’s footsteps, signing with the Atlanta Braves in 2015 as a teenager. He made his MLB debut in 2020, quickly impressing scouts and fans with his offensive power. In 2022, he earned his first All-Star selection and later joined the Milwaukee Brewers, where he has blossomed into one of the most dynamic catchers in the league.
Two Brothers, One Position
It’s uncommon for siblings to make it to the major leagues. But it’s even more extraordinary that both Contreras brothers have excelled at the same demanding position: catcher.
- Willson Contreras
- Age: 33
- Position: Catcher
- Team: St. Louis Cardinals
- Debut: 2016 (Chicago Cubs)
- Highlights: 3× All-Star, 2016 World Series Champion, known for fiery leadership, powerful bat, and a strong arm.
- William Contreras
- Age: 27
- Position: Catcher
- Team: Milwaukee Brewers
- Debut: 2020 (Atlanta Braves)
- Highlights: 2× All-Star, Silver Slugger Award winner, emerging as one of the top offensive catchers in the National League.
Willson is the veteran leader with a reputation for intensity and clutch performances. William brings youth, athleticism, and a modern offensive approach, quickly becoming a cornerstone for Milwaukee’s future.
Different Paths to MLB Stardom
Although they share the same position and passion, their journeys were unique.
Willson spent several seasons in the Cubs’ minor league system, shifting positions before finally settling behind the plate. His leadership skills and strong work ethic helped him break through in 2016. His contributions to the Cubs’ championship run made him an icon in Chicago. After years of success, he made a bold move in 2023 by signing with the St. Louis Cardinals, one of Chicago’s biggest rivals. This move marked a new chapter in his career as a veteran leader.
William’s rise came through the Braves’ deep farm system. Known for his bat-first potential, he proved himself quickly and earned national attention with his offensive production. After joining the Brewers, he became their starting catcher and has since emerged as one of the league’s most consistent performers, blending power hitting with improving defensive skills.
Family Ties in a Fierce Rivalry
The fact that the Contreras brothers now play for rival teams in the National League Central — Willson with the Cardinals and William with the Brewers — adds a unique twist to their story.
Every time St. Louis and Milwaukee meet, fans are treated to a rare sight: two elite catchers who happen to be brothers, calling games on opposite sides of the diamond. Their parents often attend these matchups wearing split jerseys, proudly representing both teams.
The brothers have admitted that competing against each other feels surreal, but they embrace the challenge. During the game, they are opponents. Off the field, they remain each other’s biggest supporters. Their mutual respect is evident every time they speak about each other’s accomplishments.
A Shared All-Star Stage
In 2022, the Contreras brothers made history when both were selected to the National League All-Star team. Willson started at catcher, while William served as the designated hitter. It was one of the few times in modern baseball history that two brothers appeared together in the same All-Star lineup.
That moment wasn’t just about baseball — it was about family. Standing side by side in their All-Star uniforms, they represented years of hard work, sacrifice, and shared dreams.
Impact on the 2025 MLB Season
The 2025 season has further highlighted their talents:
- William Contreras has been one of the Milwaukee Brewers’ most valuable players. He’s hitting for both average and power, leading the team’s offense, and showing improved leadership behind the plate. His performance has made him a strong contender for National League MVP honors.
- Willson Contreras, despite early-season injuries, has been a steady presence for the St. Louis Cardinals. His veteran experience, leadership, and ability to handle young pitchers have been crucial for a team undergoing transition. He remains one of the most respected catchers in the game.
Their simultaneous success has kept both brothers in the spotlight, proving that their achievements are not a one-time story but a sustained legacy.
Why Their Story Matters to Fans
The story of the Contreras brothers resonates deeply with baseball fans because it represents more than just athletic achievement:
- Family Legacy: Two brothers at the same position, thriving at the highest level.
- Inspiration: Their journey from Venezuela inspires aspiring athletes worldwide.
- Rivalry and Brotherhood: Their presence in opposing dugouts adds a compelling personal angle to Brewers–Cardinals matchups.
- Consistency: Both have maintained elite performance over several seasons, proving their staying power.
- Authenticity: Their relationship is genuine, heartfelt, and easy for fans to connect with.
Their journey blends competition, loyalty, and cultural pride in a way that few stories in baseball can match.
A Lasting Legacy in Baseball
So, are Willson Contreras and William Contreras brothers? Yes — and their bond runs deeper than the game itself. They are brothers, rivals, teammates in spirit, and inspirations to fans across the world. From their backyard in Venezuela to the biggest stages in Major League Baseball, their story is one of determination, talent, and family pride.
Whether they’re starting side by side in an All-Star Game or facing each other in a fierce divisional showdown, the Contreras brothers continue to make history every time they step on the field.
What’s your favorite Contreras brothers moment? Share your thoughts below and join the conversation about one of MLB’s most inspiring families.