Prime Video’s gripping new psychological thriller, The Better Sister, launched on May 29, 2025, and it’s already sparking buzz thanks to its powerful plot and stellar performances. At the core of the series is the Better Sister cast—a perfectly chosen group of actors that bring a layered, emotional story of family, betrayal, and justice to life. Set against the sleek backdrop of New York’s publishing world and criminal justice system, the show explores what happens when the past refuses to stay buried.
Table of Contents
Spotlight on the Better Sister Cast
At the heart of this suspense-driven drama are two powerhouse performances. Jessica Biel stars as Chloe Taylor, a successful executive editor at a top magazine. Her world begins to unravel after the shocking murder of her husband. Chloe’s poised exterior hides years of secrets that begin to surface under the pressure of the investigation.
Opposite Biel is Elizabeth Banks, who plays Nicky Macintosh, Chloe’s older sister with a troubled past. Once estranged, the sisters are thrown together again as suspicion around Chloe’s husband’s murder grows. Banks delivers a gritty, emotionally raw performance that challenges the viewer’s assumptions about morality and redemption.
Here’s a look at the full Better Sister cast:
- Jessica Biel as Chloe Taylor – polished, driven, and protective of her son.
- Elizabeth Banks as Nicky Macintosh – fiercely independent with a painful history.
- Corey Stoll as Adam Macintosh – Chloe’s murdered husband and Nicky’s ex.
- Maxwell Acee Donovan as Ethan Macintosh – the son caught in the family’s crossfire.
- Kim Dickens as Detective Nancy Guidry – seasoned and sharp, leading the murder probe.
- Bobby Naderi as Detective Matt Bowen – Guidry’s determined partner.
- Lorraine Toussaint as Catherine Lancaster – Chloe’s mentor and boss at the magazine.
- Gabriel Sloyer as Jake Rodriguez – a friend with complicated loyalties.
- Matthew Modine as Bill Braddock – a partner at Adam’s law firm with secrets of his own.
- Gloria Reuben as Michelle Sanders – a legal powerhouse involved in the unfolding trial.
This cast injects intensity, nuance, and humanity into every episode, turning what could be a standard murder mystery into a compelling psychological study.
Why the Better Sister Cast Works So Well
What makes the Better Sister cast so effective is the chemistry between its leads and the careful casting of each supporting role. Jessica Biel’s portrayal of Chloe balances vulnerability with fierce maternal instincts. Meanwhile, Elizabeth Banks brings grit and an undercurrent of pain that adds authenticity to Nicky’s path of recovery and confrontation.
The ensemble doesn’t just support the leads—they elevate them. Lorraine Toussaint adds gravitas as a mentor who may know more than she admits, while Corey Stoll’s presence looms large even posthumously, as secrets from his past unravel through the eyes of others.
Bullet points that explain the cast’s impact:
- Realistic tension: Biel and Banks portray sisterhood with all its affection, rivalry, and regrets.
- Well-rounded secondary characters: No one feels like filler—each role adds depth.
- Natural performances: Viewers praise how emotionally grounded the acting feels, even in tense scenes.
The casting choices avoid stereotypes, opting instead for emotional complexity. Each character has motives, history, and consequences—traits that draw viewers into the story deeper with every episode.
Fresh Faces, Familiar Talent
While established actors lead the series, newer faces like Maxwell Acee Donovan bring freshness to the screen. His portrayal of Ethan, the teenage son grappling with grief, divided loyalties, and new truths, gives younger audiences a point of emotional entry into the story.
Additionally, Kim Dickens and Bobby Naderi ground the procedural element of the story. As detectives, their sharp yet weary personas contrast well with the volatile family drama at the center. These performances keep the series tightly paced, even as it explores emotional terrain.
Streaming Now: Where to Watch the Better Sister Cast Shine
All eight episodes of The Better Sister are now available on Prime Video. Viewers can stream the series in full and dive into the layered performances of a cast that delivers on every emotional beat. The pacing, performances, and production quality position this series as one of Prime Video’s top dramatic releases of 2025.
This is not just another whodunit—it’s a deeply human story carried by actors who understand the emotional stakes of every scene.
Whether you’re here for the suspense, the psychological drama, or simply to see incredible performances, The Better Sister delivers. Don’t miss the standout work from this cast—stream it now and decide for yourself who really is the better sister.
Start watching today and see why The Better Sister cast is the talk of 2025. Their performances will stay with you long after the credits roll.