Justin Baldoni, actor and director best known for his work on “It Ends With Us,” has faced a significant legal setback this week as a judge dismissed his $400 million countersuit against Blake Lively and Ryan Reynolds. The decision, handed down by Judge Lewis J. Liman on June 9, 2025, marks a pivotal moment in a high-profile Hollywood dispute that has captured public attention for months. The court also dismissed Baldoni’s additional $250 million defamation claim against The New York Times, further narrowing the scope of his legal battle.
The judge ruled that the allegations against Lively, Reynolds, and their publicist did not meet the legal standards required for defamation or extortion. Specifically, Judge Liman noted that the statements made by Lively in her official complaint were privileged, while claims against Reynolds, publicist Leslie Sloane, and The New York Times lacked evidence that they seriously doubted the truth of their statements. However, Baldoni’s legal team retains the option to amend claims related to breach of implied covenant and tortious interference with contract.
The Legal Rollercoaster for Justin Baldoni
This dismissal is the latest twist in a saga that began when Blake Lively filed a lawsuit against Justin Baldoni, alleging sexual harassment and retaliation on the set of their film. Baldoni has consistently denied these allegations and responded with his own countersuit, accusing Lively, Reynolds, and their associates of orchestrating a smear campaign. His legal team argued that the accusations were part of a calculated effort to damage his reputation and career.
Recent developments have seen Lively voluntarily drop two of her claims—intentional and negligent infliction of emotional distress—as part of a routine streamlining of her case. Meanwhile, Baldoni’s legal team has faced setbacks, including a journalist’s admission that a key text message cited in his lawsuit contained an error, further undermining his position.
What’s Next for Justin Baldoni and the Case?
Despite the dismissal, the legal drama is far from over. The judge’s ruling allows Baldoni’s attorneys to amend certain claims, keeping the door open for revised arguments. The main trial, where both Baldoni and Lively are expected to testify, is currently scheduled for March 2026. This ongoing legal battle underscores the complex interplay of celebrity, reputation, and the justice system.
For now, Justin Baldoni must regroup and consider his next legal steps. The public will be watching closely as the case continues to unfold, with both sides preparing for a courtroom showdown that could have lasting implications for all involved.
Want to stay updated on the latest developments in the Justin Baldoni case? Sign up for our newsletter and never miss a breaking story.