Katie Thurston Slams Bachelorette Costar for Rude Wedding Pic Comment after reacting sharply to a remark left by former cast member Cody Menk on her wedding photos. The exchange quickly became a hot topic among Bachelor Nation fans, showcasing Katie’s trademark wit and her unwillingness to let a rude comment slide.
Earlier this week, Katie shared joyful images from her April wedding to comedian Jeff Arcuri. Among the many congratulatory messages from friends and followers, one stood out for all the wrong reasons. Cody Menk, who appeared on Katie’s season of The Bachelorette in 2021, left a remark that read, “Good couple! Both solid 5s.” The comment, perceived as a backhanded insult, didn’t go unnoticed by the bride.
Table of Contents
Katie’s Response
Instead of ignoring the jab, Katie took to her Instagram Stories to share a screenshot of the comment. Adding her own caption, she wrote, “Remember this guy from my season? Me neither. But apparently, he’s still following along. Thanks for being a fan.” The message was delivered with a laughing-crying emoji, turning the awkward moment into a light-hearted clapback.
She later revealed that she had blocked Menk after seeing the remark. “Guess I’ll never know what else he had to say now,” she added with a touch of humor. Fans were quick to praise her for standing her ground and handling the situation with both confidence and charm.
A Look Back at Their History
Cody Menk was a contestant during Katie’s 2021 season of The Bachelorette, but his time on the show was short-lived. He was eliminated during the second week and never formed a strong connection with Katie on-screen. Given their brief interaction, fans were surprised to see him commenting on such a personal life event years later.
The comment sparked a wave of discussions across social media. Many fans supported Katie, noting that public figures often deal with unnecessary criticism, even during moments that should be purely celebratory.
Katie’s Strength Beyond Reality TV
While this social media moment made headlines, it’s only a small chapter in Katie Thurston’s story this year. In early 2025, she revealed her breast cancer diagnosis, an announcement that was met with an outpouring of love and support from fans worldwide. Throughout her treatment, Katie has remained open about her journey, sharing updates on her progress and encouraging others to prioritize their health.
In July, she shared uplifting news that her tumors were responding positively to treatment. Her transparency has inspired countless followers, proving that she’s more than just a reality TV personality—she’s also a voice for resilience and self-advocacy.
Why This Moment Resonates
The wedding comment incident resonated with many because it highlighted the challenges of living life in the public eye. Even during milestones like marriage, public figures can face unsolicited judgments. Katie’s decision to address the comment publicly, while maintaining her sense of humor, turned what could have been a negative moment into an empowering one.
Fans pointed out that her response also served as a reminder to speak up against rudeness, even when it comes from familiar faces from the past. For Katie, the best revenge seemed to be showcasing her happiness and joy alongside her new husband.
Public Reaction
The reaction from Bachelor Nation was swift and overwhelmingly in Katie’s favor.
- Many applauded her for “calling it like it is” and not letting the remark go unanswered.
- Others admired her ability to make a point without resorting to hostility.
- Some expressed surprise that Cody Menk was still following her online after their brief time together on the show.
The moment became a trending discussion among fans, further cementing Katie’s reputation for being outspoken, quick-witted, and unafraid to confront disrespect.
Looking Ahead
As Katie continues her married life with Jeff Arcuri and focuses on her health, it’s clear that she’s not letting negativity overshadow her personal milestones. Whether sharing moments of joy or updates on her treatment, she continues to connect with her audience through honesty and humor.
Her recent interaction with a former Bachelorette costar might have been brief, but it served as a reminder that Katie Thurston is as candid off-screen as she was on the show. Her ability to turn criticism into a moment of empowerment is one of the qualities that has kept fans invested in her journey.
Katie’s story continues to evolve—on social media, in her personal life, and in the hearts of those who admire her authenticity. As she moves forward, she does so with the same unapologetic voice that made her a standout from the moment she appeared on television.