King Charles’s recent visit to Canada has ignited a wave of frustration among First Nations communities, many of whom believe the nation is experiencing a troubling backslide in its reconciliation efforts. Although his arrival was framed as a symbol of unity and a renewed commitment to democratic values, Indigenous leaders and advocates say these gestures are overshadowing deeper issues that remain unresolved. King Charles’s presence, rather than offering healing, is being viewed by many as a reminder of colonialism’s lingering shadow.
Table of Contents
King Charles in Canada: A Moment of Reflection or Redirection?
On May 26, 2025, King Charles and Queen Camilla began a highly publicized tour across Canada. The monarch’s itinerary included symbolic ceremonies such as a 21-gun salute, engagements with military regiments, and an address to open the new parliamentary session. His speech celebrated Canadian sovereignty, values of pluralism, and the enduring friendship between the monarchy and the people of Canada.
But for many First Nations people, this visit wasn’t about celebration. It served as a stark contrast to their ongoing fight for justice, recognition, and reparations. As King Charles was received with pomp and national pride, Indigenous communities continued to grapple with the long-standing impacts of systemic inequality, unfulfilled treaty obligations, and unaddressed land claims.
One of the key criticisms voiced was that the royal visit failed to acknowledge the painful history of colonialism and the Crown’s role in it. While ceremonies and public addresses highlight unity and patriotism, First Nations communities are asking: where is the real commitment to healing?
First Nations Leaders Demand Substance Over Symbolism
During his visit, King Charles did meet with key Indigenous representatives from the Inuit, First Nations, and Métis communities. The conversations touched on reconciliation, cultural preservation, and environmental stewardship. However, many community leaders felt the tone of the visit leaned heavily into symbolism without offering a framework for meaningful progress.
Some leaders proposed that King Charles begin his reign with a bold act: formally renouncing the Doctrine of Discovery—a principle historically used to justify the colonization and dispossession of Indigenous lands. They argue this symbolic doctrine continues to underpin legal frameworks that fail to honor Indigenous sovereignty.
Others called for the monarch to endorse a Royal Proclamation of Reconciliation. This recommendation stems directly from the Truth and Reconciliation Commission’s Calls to Action. The goal is to formalize a commitment from the Crown to move toward nation-to-nation relationships with Indigenous Peoples, rooted in mutual respect and justice.
These proposals are not new. They’ve been voiced for years. The frustration now is that, once again, a high-profile moment has passed without a tangible outcome.
King Charles’s Legacy and the Path Ahead
The visit has intensified conversations around what reconciliation truly means in modern Canada. Is it enough to speak of unity while longstanding disputes over land, water, and sovereignty continue? Is a royal tour that avoids addressing colonial history helping or hurting the healing process?
King Charles now faces a unique opportunity to redefine his role in Canada. Unlike his predecessors, he ascends the throne during a time of national reckoning with the past. The First Nations are not asking for grand speeches; they’re asking for truth, justice, and respect. Acknowledgment must be followed by action.
To move forward, Canada must do more than commemorate its values; it must live them. That includes:
- Upholding treaty commitments in both letter and spirit.
- Funding Indigenous-led education, housing, and healthcare systems.
- Returning stewardship of traditional lands to Indigenous nations.
- Reforming institutions to reflect the rights and autonomy of First Nations.
The burden does not rest solely with King Charles, but his symbolic influence can either bolster or diminish national efforts. If he wishes to be remembered as a monarch of the people, he must listen to those whose voices have long been ignored.
Reconciliation is not a gesture; it is a journey. King Charles’s visit has reminded Canada of how far it still has to go. Support Indigenous communities by amplifying their voices, advocating for justice, and pushing for real accountability from both the Crown and Canadian institutions.