As Halloween 2025 arrives, fans of Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark have reason to celebrate. The chilling anthology, based on Alvin Schwartz’s iconic horror books, is back in conversation thanks to new updates about the long-awaited sequel and renewed interest across streaming platforms.
Table of Contents
The Legacy of Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark
Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark began as a children’s book series written by Alvin Schwartz and illustrated by Stephen Gammell. First published in the early 1980s, the trilogy became famous — and sometimes infamous — for its haunting tales and terrifying black-and-white artwork.
For decades, the books were both banned and beloved in American schools. Parents debated their frightening content, while kids traded copies like forbidden treasures. The series became one of the most checked-out titles in U.S. libraries throughout the 1990s and early 2000s.
How the 2019 Film Revived the Horror Classic
In 2019, Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark leapt from page to screen. Directed by André Øvredal and produced by Guillermo del Toro, the film adapted several of Schwartz’s most iconic stories — including Harold, The Big Toe, and The Red Spot.
The movie grossed more than $104 million worldwide, a remarkable success for a PG-13 horror film. Critics praised its nostalgic tone, practical effects, and respect for the source material. The film perfectly balanced fear and adventure, appealing to both longtime fans and a younger generation discovering the tales for the first time.
Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark Sequel: Latest 2025 Update
After years of speculation, news surrounding the Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark sequel finally gained momentum in 2025.
According to director André Øvredal, the sequel’s production is now “actively moving forward.” During an interview in early October 2025, Øvredal confirmed that the script is finished and approved, with production expected to begin in 2026.
Guillermo del Toro, who co-wrote the story for the first movie, is returning as producer. He has hinted that the sequel will explore “new nightmares” inspired by the remaining tales in Schwartz’s books. Fans can expect darker imagery, richer folklore, and new creatures designed with practical effects rather than heavy CGI.
Øvredal told Collider earlier this month, “We want the sequel to feel like it belongs in the same universe but with fresh horrors that even longtime fans won’t predict.”
Where to Watch Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark This Halloween
As of October 2025, Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark is available on several streaming platforms for Halloween viewing.
Here’s where you can find it:
- Netflix U.S. – Streaming until November 15, 2025
- Paramount+ – Available to subscribers through the CBS Films catalog
- Amazon Prime Video – Rent or buy in 4K UHD
- Apple TV+ Store – Purchase or rent individually
Meanwhile, the original Scary Stories book trilogy remains in print, with HarperCollins releasing a special 40th Anniversary Edition in September 2025. The new edition includes restored artwork from Stephen Gammell and a foreword celebrating the cultural impact of the series.
Why the Series Still Scares (and Delights) Readers Decades Later
So why does Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark still haunt the imagination of American readers?
Experts say it’s the combination of childhood curiosity and genuine psychological fear. Unlike many modern horror stories, Schwartz’s tales are short, simple, and eerie enough to linger in memory. The stories rely on folklore and urban legends, giving them a sense of realism that makes readers wonder if they could actually happen.
Moreover, Stephen Gammell’s artwork continues to terrify and fascinate. His distorted figures, misty textures, and unsettling faces are instantly recognizable — the kind of imagery that defined an entire generation’s idea of horror.
The Cultural Revival of Nostalgic Horror
The renewed interest in Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark reflects a larger cultural trend. Across streaming services and social media, nostalgic horror is booming.
TikTok users share dramatic readings of the original stories, while YouTube creators review the 1980s books in Halloween-themed videos. Hashtags like #ScaryStoriesToTellInTheDark and #HorrorNostalgia have millions of views.
Meanwhile, fans are revisiting other childhood fright classics such as Goosebumps and Are You Afraid of the Dark?—but Scary Stories continues to stand out for its darker tone and haunting art.
What Fans Want from the Upcoming Sequel
Since the sequel’s announcement, online forums have been filled with speculation about which stories will appear next.
Fans are especially eager to see adaptations of:
- The Haunted House
- The Drum
- Oh Susannah
- The Wendigo
Many also hope that the new film will dive deeper into the character of Stella Nicholls, the brave teenager from the 2019 movie, played by Zoe Colletti. As of October 2025, her return has not been officially confirmed, but both Øvredal and del Toro have hinted that the original cast could return.
Scary Stories’ Influence on Modern Horror
It’s impossible to overstate how influential Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark has been on American horror culture.
Many modern filmmakers and authors credit the books for inspiring their love of storytelling. Directors like Mike Flanagan (The Haunting of Hill House) and Ari Aster (Hereditary) have cited the influence of childhood horror on their creativity.
Moreover, teachers and librarians continue to use Schwartz’s books to introduce folklore and creative writing to students. Despite earlier controversies, the series is now recognized as a literary classic for young readers.
Halloween 2025: A Perfect Time to Revisit the Tales
As Halloween night approaches, Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark has once again become part of the national conversation.
Streaming platforms are promoting it in their horror collections, bookstores are displaying the anniversary edition, and movie fans are eagerly awaiting production updates on the sequel.
Whether you first discovered the series decades ago or are reading it for the first time, its power remains the same — it makes you afraid to turn off the lights, yet too fascinated to look away.
Final Thoughts
In 2025, Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark continues to bridge generations of horror lovers. It’s both nostalgic and timeless — a perfect mix of fear and fascination that defines Halloween itself.
So, as the nights grow longer and the pumpkins glow, gather your courage and revisit these eerie tales. Whether through the books or the movie, they remain proof that a good scare never gets old.
What’s your favorite story from the series? Share your thoughts and let the Halloween spirit continue to haunt — in the best way possible.
